A gift card is a thoughtful gift when it fits the person: a store they already use, an amount that buys something complete there, and a short note that explains why you chose it. Get those right and the recipient gets to pick exactly what they want. Get them wrong and the card tends to sit in a drawer.

That drawer is well stocked. Americans hold billions of dollars in unspent gift cards, and about a third of people who give them admit they did it because they couldn't think of anything else. This guide covers how to choose, load, present and buy a card so it gets used, drawing on consumer surveys, federal rules and research on how people give and receive gifts.

Are Gift Cards a Good Gift?

For most people, yes. Gift cards are among the most popular gifts in the U.S., and more people now treat them as a budgeting tool as well as a present.

The National Retail Federation expected Americans to spend about $29 billion on gift cards during the 2025 holiday season. Gift cards were the second most popular gift, and 43% of shoppers planned to buy at least one. Shoppers aged 65 and older were the most likely to buy one (53%) and also the most likely to want one.

Demand is still growing. In Blackhawk Network's 2026 gifting study, 77% of U.S. consumers said they planned to buy gift cards this year, and the share planning to buy them for their own use nearly doubled, from 31% to 56%. When people buy gift cards for themselves, they are treating them as money to spend, which should reassure anyone worried that a card looks like a consolation prize.

Why people give gift cards

In a 2024 Bankrate/YouGov survey, 84% of U.S. adults said they had given a gift card as a present. Most gave reasons that show some thought: they knew the person could use it (48%), they picked a store the person likes (42%), or it seemed practical (37%). Another 32% said they gave one because they didn't know what else to buy. The rest of this guide is about staying out of that last group.

Why Many Gift Cards Never Get Used

The most common way a gift card fails is simple: nobody spends it.

Bankrate's 2024 survey of 2,373 adults found that 43% of Americans have at least one unused gift card, voucher or store credit, worth an average of $244 per person. That average has roughly doubled since 2021, when it was $116, and the national total comes to about $27 billion.

About a third of people (34%) say they have lost money on a gift card at some point. The most common reasons were that the card expired (20%), the card was lost (17%) or the store closed before they used it (12%).

Higher income doesn't prevent this. Among households earning $100,000 or more, 55% hold an unused card, with an average balance of $348, the highest of any income group.

For a giver, the lesson is practical: the best gift card is one the person can use soon and without effort.

Store Card or Universal Card?

When you're unsure, choose the more flexible card. Research by marketing professors Mary Steffel, Elanor Williams and Robyn LeBoeuf explains why.

What givers choose and what recipients want

Givers tend to pick cards that match who the recipient is: a bookstore card for the reader, a coffee chain card for the coffee drinker. Recipients think about what they need right now, and that changes, so they prefer cards they can use in more places. In the studies, recipients took longer to redeem cards tied to one retailer, or cards that came with a suggestion for how to spend them, than cards they could use almost anywhere. Givers didn't expect that delay.

The gap was widest with the people closest to the giver. Givers chose more specific cards for romantic partners than for friends, to show how well they knew them, while recipients wanted versatile cards whatever the relationship. A 2024 meta-analysis in Psychology & Marketing found the same kind of mismatch between givers and recipients across many gift-giving studies.

How to choose

  • If you know exactly where they shop, and they go often, a store or restaurant card works well: their grocery store, the coffee shop on their commute, the hardware store they visit on weekends.
  • If you know their interests but not what they need right now, go one level broader, such as a large bookseller instead of a small specialty shop, or a card that works at several restaurants.
  • If you're not sure, choose a widely accepted card: a large retailer that sells many kinds of products, or a prepaid Visa, Mastercard or American Express card. Prepaid network cards usually carry a purchase fee, covered below.

If you can, ask. Steffel's own advice is that asking is the most reliable way to give something the person will enjoy, and other research supports it. A 2011 study in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology found that people appreciated gifts they had asked for more than gifts chosen for them, and that givers underestimated this. If someone asks for a card to their favorite bookstore, that card shows you listened.

How Much Should You Put on a Gift Card?

Choose an amount that pays for something complete at that store. For most holiday gifts, $25 is a sensible minimum.

Consumer data compiled by Capital One Shopping suggests fewer than 7% of holiday gift card recipients expect less than $25, while about 38% expect $50 or more. In NRF's 2025 holiday survey, the average shopper planned to spend a little over $50 per card.

Match the amount to the store

Twenty dollars at a steakhouse covers an appetizer; at a coffee shop it covers several drinks. Check the menu or price range before you decide. A card that pays for a whole meal, book or item feels generous, while one that covers half of something feels like a discount coupon. For restaurants, allow for tax and tip.

An amount that fits the store's prices also reduces leftover balances. Small remainders, like 47 cents after a coffee, are the ones people forget.

If you're contributing toward something bigger, say so. "For the headphones you've been saving for" sets the right expectation. "Dinner's on me" does not if the card covers half the bill.

Typical amounts by relationship

RecipientCommon range
Teacher, coach or service provider$10-$25
Coworker or office gift exchange$15-$30
Friend$25-$50
Close family member$50-$100
PartnerYour usual gift budget

These are common U.S. norms. Adjust them to your budget and local prices.

Digital or Physical Gift Card?

Physical cards are easier to wrap and hand over. Digital cards arrive instantly and are easy to keep on a phone.

Blackhawk's 2026 research found physical cards are still the preferred format overall, though nearly a third of consumers like having both options. Recipients may be more open to digital cards than givers assume: a 2023 study in Psychology & Marketing found that givers were less likely to choose digital cards than recipients were to want them, partly because givers overestimated concerns that a digital card is a less appropriate gift.

 Physical cardDigital card
Best forIn-person celebrations, wrapped gifts, older relativesLong-distance gifts, last-minute occasions, people who shop online
AdvantagesFeels like something to openArrives instantly; easy to keep in a phone wallet
RisksEasy to lose; can be tampered with on store racksCan land in spam or get buried in an inbox
TipPut it in a greeting card with a small itemSchedule delivery for the day and send a text so they look for it

You can also combine the two: buy a digital card, then print it or write the code inside a greeting card. Before sending a digital card, double-check the email address or phone number.

How to Make a Gift Card Personal

The card takes care of the practical part, and the thought shows in what comes with it. In Bankrate's survey, 11% of Americans said they find gift cards impersonal. A few small touches address most of that.

Write a note that explains the choice

One or two sentences is enough if they connect the card to the person's life:

  • "For your Saturday coffee runs. The next few are on me."
  • "You've been talking about redoing the balcony. Go pick out the plants you want."
  • "Congratulations on the new place. This should cover the first grocery trip."
  • "A contribution toward the camera you keep talking about."

You don't need to apologize for giving a card. Explain it warmly and leave the choice to them. "Maybe something for the balcony" is a suggestion; naming the exact item to buy takes the choice away.

Pair the card with a plan or a small item

A restaurant card paired with an offer to babysit that night is often worth more to parents than the balance itself. A small related item in the $5 to $10 range makes opening the gift feel like a gift: a bookmark with a bookstore card, a bag of beans with a coffee card. You'll find more small add-on ideas in The Seahurst's guide to thoughtful gifts and home goods. The extra item is optional. On a tight budget, putting the money on the card usually serves the recipient better.

For a digital card, a short video or voice message can take the place of a greeting card.

Make the card easy to use

Write the balance and the store's balance-check website on the envelope. Mention that many digital cards can be added to a phone wallet so they're at hand at checkout. Pass along any restrictions, such as online-only use or excluded products, so the recipient doesn't discover them at the register.

Fees, Expiration Dates and Your Rights

Federal law sets minimum protections for gift cards, and some states add more. A few details are worth checking before you buy.

What federal law guarantees

The Credit CARD Act of 2009 and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's Regulation E set these rules:

  • Gift card funds generally can't expire until at least five years after the card was issued or money was last loaded onto it. The date printed on a physical card can be earlier than the date the funds expire.
  • Inactivity and service fees are allowed only after 12 months without use, must be disclosed, and are limited to one per month.
  • The rules cover both store gift cards and network-branded prepaid gift cards. Some promotional and loyalty cards are excluded.

State laws can go further

California bans expiration dates on most gift cards and, since April 1, 2026, requires businesses to give cash for balances under $15 on request, the highest threshold in the country. About ten states have cash-out rules of some kind: Washington requires cash back for balances under $5, and Massachusetts once 90% of the card's value has been used. The rules that apply depend on the state, so check where the recipient lives.

Purchase fees on prepaid network cards

Store gift cards are usually sold at face value. Prepaid Visa, Mastercard and American Express gift cards typically add a one-time purchase fee of about $3 to $7, depending on the card amount and where you buy it. If you want the recipient to get the full amount, add the fee to your budget.

Avoid stores that may close

In Bankrate's survey, 12% of people lost gift card value because a store closed before they used the card. If a retailer is closing locations or has filed for bankruptcy, choose a different one.

How to Buy Gift Cards Safely

A card whose balance has been stolen is worse than no gift at all. Two kinds of fraud are worth knowing about.

Card draining

Thieves take cards from store racks, record the card number and PIN, reseal the packaging and put the cards back. When a shopper activates the card at checkout, the thieves spend the balance. Recipients often wait weeks before using a card, so the theft can go unnoticed for a long time.

This is a current problem. In spring 2026, Texas investigators recovered more than 11,500 tampered cards from one ring and estimated they had prevented about $5.7 million in losses. In September 2026, the Texas Financial Crimes Intelligence Center reported four arrests in a separate ring that had spread from Texas into Arkansas.

Safe-buying checklist

Based on guidance from the Federal Trade Commission:

  • Buy from stores you know or directly from the retailer's website.
  • Avoid gift cards sold on auction or resale sites, where they may be fake or stolen.
  • Inspect the packaging. If the PIN is exposed, a sticker looks replaced or the package seems resealed, pick another card and tell a cashier.
  • When possible, buy cards kept behind the counter, and ask the cashier to confirm the balance after activation.
  • Keep the receipt and a photo of the back of the card, and let the recipient know you have them.

Gift cards are for gifts, not payments

The second scam targets the person holding the card. Fraudsters pose as the IRS, tech support, an employer or a relative in trouble and demand payment in gift cards. The FTC's position is simple: anyone who insists on payment by gift card is a scammer. Consumers reported $15.9 billion in fraud losses to the FTC in 2025, and in an earlier FTC analysis about one in four people who lost money to fraud said they had paid with a gift card.

If a card you gave or received was compromised, contact the card issuer right away. Getting the money back isn't guaranteed, which is why prevention matters.

Gift Card Etiquette

When gift cards work well

  • Graduations, new homes and new babies, when people face real expenses.
  • Teachers, coaches and service providers.
  • Coworkers and office gift exchanges with a set budget.
  • Teens and young adults, who usually prefer to choose for themselves.

When to think twice

For an anniversary or another romantic milestone, a card on its own can feel transactional, so pair it with a plan. If someone asked for a specific item, give them that item if you can. For your boss, a group card from the team is safer, since in most U.S. workplaces gifts go from managers to employees. And skip the card if the person rarely shops at the store, lives far from it, or finds online checkout difficult. In that case, browse all our gift ideas and home guides for something they'll actually use.

FAQ

Should you tell them the amount?
You don't need to announce it, but make it easy to find. Writing the balance on the envelope helps them plan how to use the card.
Is it OK to regift a gift card?
Generally yes, if the card is unused, has its full balance and suits the new recipient. Check the balance and the terms first.