A sweater is a cozy gift, but it's also the kind most likely to go back to the store. Clothing makes up about 65% of holiday returns, and the top reason for returns overall is wrong size (44%). Here's how to get it right, and how to wrap it nicely.

Step 1: Find Their Size Without Asking

  • Check a sweater they already wear. Look at the tag when it's in the laundry or hanging up.
  • Ask someone close to them: a partner, roommate, sibling.
  • Look at past orders if you share an online account.
  • Lay a favorite sweater flat and measure across the chest, armpit to armpit. Compare with the size chart of the brand you're buying.
  • Not sure? Go a little bigger. A slightly loose sweater is fine. A tight one gets returned.

Step 2: Choose the Right Fabric

FabricFeels likeGood forWatch out
Merino woolsoft, warm, not itchy for mosta nicer gift, cold climatesgentle wash or hand wash
Regular woolvery warm, can be scratchyoutdoor typesitchy for some people
Cottonsoft, breathablemild weather, people who hate woolless warm
Cashmerevery soft, lighta splurgepricey, needs care
Acrylic blendssoft, easya budget gift, easy washingcan pill over time

Step 3: Check the Exchange Rules

Before you buy, find out:

  • how many days they have to exchange it;
  • whether you can get a gift receipt;
  • whether personalized or custom pieces can be returned at all. Often they can't.

Put the gift receipt in the card, not under the tissue paper where it gets thrown away.

Make It Personal: A Hometown Sweater

That's a good example of a sweater gift that feels personal: a sweatshirt or knit with someone's town, neighborhood or old school on it. It shows you thought about them, not just their size.

It pairs well with other local-pride gifts, like Ebbets Field caps or a neighborhood blanket.

How to Wrap a Sweater Gift

Option 1: In a Box

  1. Lay the sweater face down. Fold each sleeve across the back.
  2. Fold both sides in so it's as wide as the box.
  3. Fold the bottom up in half or thirds.
  4. Line the box with tissue paper, put the sweater in face up, fold the tissue over the top.
  5. Close the box and wrap it like any other box.

Option 2: A Soft Bundle (No Box)

  1. Fold the sweater as above, then roll it tightly from the bottom up.
  2. Wrap the roll in a few sheets of tissue paper.
  3. Wrap that in kraft paper or fabric, like a big candy, and twist the ends.
  4. Tie the ends with ribbon or twine. Tuck in a sprig of greenery or a name tag.

The soft bundle is faster and looks great under a tree. The box keeps the sweater from wrinkling if it has to travel.

What to look for

  • Size: when unsure, go a little bigger - a loose sweater is fine, a tight one gets returned.
  • Fabric: merino wool is the safest nicer-gift choice; cotton suits people who dislike wool.
  • Exchange window: confirm how many days they have and whether a gift receipt is included.
  • Personalized pieces: custom sweaters often can't be returned, so size matters even more.
  • Wrapping: a box protects against wrinkling in transit; a soft bundle is faster and still looks great.

FAQ

How do I find someone's sweater size without asking them?
Check the tag on a sweater they already wear, ask someone close to them, look at past online orders, or lay a favorite sweater flat and measure chest width against the brand's size chart. When in doubt, go slightly bigger.
What fabric should I pick for a sweater gift?
Merino wool is a safe, soft choice for most people. Cotton works well for mild weather or people who find wool itchy, and cashmere is a splurge option that needs more care.
Can I return a personalized sweater if the size is wrong?
Often not. Custom or personalized pieces are frequently non-returnable, so it's worth confirming the exchange policy before buying and getting the size right up front.